top of page

B-BBEE IN SA, SUPRISING ROOTS & LESSONS IN BROADER OWNERSHIP

Many people might be surprised to learn that South Africa's Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) policy has roots in a distant land with deep historical and cultural ties: Malaysia. Cape Town's vibrant Malay community itself is a testament to this shared heritage.


In the 1970s, Malaysia faced a similar economic challenge. Prime Minister Abdul Razak, recognizing the need for a more inclusive economy, launched the renowned New Economic Policy (NEP). This aimed to empower the indigenous Malays (Bumiputras) whose economic participation lagged far behind the Chinese and other foreign groups.


The NEP, implemented after racial unrest in 1969, used government procurement, licensing, and financial support to encourage Bumiputra business ownership. While it fell short of its ambitious 30% target, the policy undeniably achieved significant progress.


Here's what we can learn from Malaysia's experience:

  • Poverty Reduction and Wealth Creation: Bumiputra wealth ownership grew substantially, from a mere 4% in 1970 to roughly 20% in 1997. National wealth also flourished, with per capita income rising significantly. Absolute poverty rates plummeted from 50% to a remarkable 6.8%.

  • Improved Income Equality: The Gini coefficient, a measure of wealth distribution, showed a positive shift from 0.513 in 1970 to 0.446 in 1997, indicating a narrowing gap between rich and poor.


Challenges remain, of course. Critics have raised concerns about the accuracy of government statistics and the potential for wealth concentration within the Bumiputra community. However, the overall trend towards greater economic participation is undeniable.


Lessons for South Africa's BEE Journey

South Africa's BEE policy, while facing similar criticisms regarding wealth concentration, holds immense potential for positive change. Here are some key takeaways:

  • Broadening Ownership:  Learning from Malaysia's experience, South Africa should prioritize broadening ownership opportunities within the black population to ensure the benefits of BEE reach a wider base. Initiatives like accessible share ownership schemes can play a crucial role in achieving this.

  • Education as the Cornerstone:  Investing in quality education, particularly for black students pursuing relevant skills and qualifications, is paramount. An empowered and skilled black workforce is the bedrock of sustainable economic growth and shared prosperity.

  • Moving Beyond Dependence:  While acknowledging the initial support structures, it's essential to encourage black businesses to transition from beneficiary to self-sustaining entities. Building a culture of ownership and entrepreneurship is key to long-term success.


South Africa's BEE journey, while acknowledging the need for adjustments, presents a compelling opportunity to create a more inclusive and equitable economy. By learning from Malaysia's policy and prioritizing education, broader ownership, and self-sustaining black businesses, we can strive towards a future where economic empowerment truly uplifts all South Africans.


11 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page